What would become the Lindsey Chapel Cemetery probably had its beginning with the earliest known grave and tombstone for Mary C. ROBERTSON, b. Dec 5, 1845: d. Apr 26, 1846. Mary was the daughter of Thomas Edward and Jane Caroline [JARRETT] ROBERTSON and a granddaughter of Lindsey and Delilah. She was probably the first death in the ROBERTSON family after their move to Missouri.
It was probably Lindsey who selected the high area across from the family home, which is now just southeast of the corner of Lynn Avenue and Miller Road. Whether Lindsey and Delilah envisioned the growth of their family burial site to a cemetery of over 570 graves will never be known.
The next burial was probably about two years later. William F. STEELE, b. May 8, 1809: d. Jul 22, 1848, was apparently a family friend with no direct relationship to the ROBERTSON family. His widow, Roxanna, later married John Andrew RAY. Both were buried at the cemetery in 1875 and 1876. William’s daughter from his earlier marriage, Anna Elizabeth STEELE, had been buried next to her father in 1862.
The third burial at the cemetery was probably Lindsey’s sister, Lucy ROBERTSON, b. Feb 14, 1799: d. Dec 1, 1849. Lucy was the wife of Alexander McCULLAH, Jr., b. Jul 16, 1793: d. Apr 18, 1856. They had arrived in Greene County about a month before her death. Alexander was buried beside her in 1856. The fourth burial was probably Lindsey’s third son, Samuel H. ROBERTSON, b. Dec 12, 1823: d. Sep 22, 1853. The fifth burial was probably an infant grandson of Lindsey, b. Jun 6, 1855: d. Jun 12, 1855. His parents were Warham A. and Stella Jane [ROBERTSON] McELHANY.
Burials in the next decade included Lindsey’s sister, Mary “Polly” [ROBERTSON] HAGEWOOD, b. 1791: d. Feb 24, 1861; Lindsey ROBERTSON, b. Oct 13, 1792: d. Jul 29, 1861; Lindsey’s second son. Thomas Edward ROBERTSON, b. Dec 17, 1821: d. Feb 2, 1863; and Sarah [JONES] O’BRYANT, b. Jul 29, 1797: d. Jan 12, 1867. Sarah, wife of Elias O’BRYANT, was a sister to Delilah [JONES] ROBERTSON. Another sister to Lindsey, Mickey [ROBERTSON] SMITH, died in the early 1850s. Her grave has not been located, but a burial in the family cemetery would have been likely.
These early burials at Lindsey Chapel Cemetery are identified by their tombstones. There may have been other early burials in unmarked graves, or their tombstones have been lost or are illegible.